Pages

Thursday, 6 November 2014

Harrison Bergeron: Or How Reading is Not Always Good for Mental Health

Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut is a story set in a future where everyone is exactly equal. It’s sort of the short story equivalent to an Ayn Rand novel. When reading, it also reminded me of The Trees by Rush, a favourite song of my families for long car rides to the cottage. Harrison Bergeron revolves around the theme of strict equality and gives an extreme case of what this can do to a society. I decided to read this story because I’ve wanted to read Slaughterhouse 5 for a while now, but haven’t been able to get around to it. It doesn’t look like it will happen this year either so I decided to just wet my appetite with a short story by Vonnegut instead.

After reading this a couple of times…I’m not quite sure what to make of it. I think I really liked it... I think? I think it caught me by surprise. It seems so simple and ridiculous that it shouldn’t be taken seriously and yet, I couldn’t help but be drawn in by the images of it. I have a very distinct picture in my head about how it would all look.  The images in my head really contrast the normalcy of the Bergeron family in their house with my idea of how bizarre Harrison would look like with all his “handicaps.”

I think I was also surprised by the story because the opening little bit didn’t prepare me for how much I would feel later on. I found that until I came to the part where Harrison appeared on the TV and proclaimed himself Emperor, I wasn’t really engaged with the story. However, as soon as Harrison appeared I was amazed. There is a deep beauty in the simple writing of Vonnegut at this point. Just the divergence from the strange normality of the beginning of the story to the crazy claims of the 14 year old and his short love with his Empress left a deep impression on me.

Then the story became deeply simple…and sad. All it took to destroy the love and beauty was a double barrel shotgun. Both the Emperor and Empress die and the story returns to Mr. and Mrs. Bergeron. The sad routine of their lives carries on without thought of what happened, or what could have happened. When reading, I went from really happy to really sad very quickly. Again, another twist, just as I started getting in the story, really enjoying it then, BOOM! and I’m back to feeling ambivalent about the story, but this time also deeply sad. But then as a final surprise, the last line literally made me laugh out loud…weird story.


As I reflect back on this story now I think I can say that I really do like it. Moreover, I think I like it for all the reasons why I wasn’t sure if I liked it at first. At the very least it was a really well written story as it definitely allowed me to enter the narrative and to feel what was going on, even if those feelings were not happy. Now excuse me while I pour myself a stiff drink and wallow in sadness for a little while.

No comments:

Post a Comment